AZERBAIJAN NATIONAL ACADEMY OF SCIENCES
ISSUES OF MULTİ-CRİTERİA EXPERT ASSESSMENT OF QUALİTY İNDİCATORS İN THE PROCESSES OF MANAGEMENT OF İNNOVATİVE TECHNİCAL PARKS
Alovsat G.Aliyev, Roza O. Shahverdiyeva

The article discusses the issues of multi-criteria expert assessments of quality indicators in the management processes of innovative technology parks. The role and importance of innovative technology parks in the economy of information and knowledge is shown. The features of the creation and management of innovative technology parks as a complex object of complex socio-economic management in the provision of innovative, scientifically based products and services are analyzed. The directions of specialization of technology parks in various fields in accordance with the trends of the industrial revolution 4.0 and the problems of managing their activities are shown. A generalized functional structure of the technology park activity, a conceptual model of the intellectual system for managing its activities is proposed. A system of indicators and criteria for managing and evaluating the effectiveness of technology parks was studied. The system of innovation and the quality indicators of innovative products/services in technology parks were studied. The scientific and theoretical foundations and features of multi-criteria expert assessments in assessing the activities of technology parks are analyzed. The results of the expert assessment of the weight coefficients of composite indice for a comparative assessment of the effectiveness of technology parks using the multicriteria method of expert evaluation were processed using a software package. Impact assessments given by experts on indices forming a composite index of technology parks are summarized and presented in the form of weights. Recommendations were given on promising areas for improving the methods of multicriteria expert assessments in assessing the effectiveness of technology parks. It was noted that the results of multicriteria expert assessments provide an important basis for effective decision-making and their implementation in decision-making processes (pp.89-104).

Keywords:information economy, industrial revolution 4.0, technopark, weight coefficient, multi-criteria expert evaluation.
DOI : 10.25045/jpis.v11.i2.08
References
  • Milli iqtisadiyyat və iqtisadiyyatın əsas sektorları üzrə Strateji Yol Xəritələri, Bakı, 6 dekabr 2016-cı il, https://www.president.az/articles/21953.
  • Elm haqqında Azərbaycan Respublikasının Qanunu. Bakı, 14 iyun 2016-cı il, http://science.gov.az/uploads/PDF/Elm_haqqinda_Azerbaycan_Respublikasinin_Qanunu.pdf
  • Centre for the Fourth Industrial Revolution Network. 2019, https://weforum.ent.box.com/v/C4IR-Brochure.
  • Khanmirzaee S., Jafari M., Akhavan P. A study on the role of science and technology parks in development of knowledge-based economy // World Journal of Entrepreneurship Management and Sustainable Development, 2018, vol. 14,  issue 1, pp.74-85. 
  • Estrella F.J., Onar S.C., Rodriguez R.M., et al. Selecting firms in University technoparks: A hesitant linguistic fuzzy TOPSIS model for heterogeneous contexts // Journal of Intelligent & Fuzzy, Systems, 2017, vol.33, issue 2, pp.1155-1172.
  • Zhao H., Guo S., Zhao H. Comprehensive benefit evaluation of ecoindustrial parks by employing the best-worst method based on circular economy and sustainability // Journal of Environment Development and Sustainability, 2018, vol.20, issue 3, pp.1229-1253.
  • Lyra R.M.,Almeida M.F.L. Measuring the performance of science and technology parks: a proposal of a multidimensional model / Conference:  Measurement Science Challenges in Natural and Social Sciences. Brazil, jul 31-aug 03, 2018, vol.1044.
  • Elena P., Pizikov S., Mukaliev N., et al. Impact of production and transaction costs on companies' performance according assessments of experts // Entrepreneurship and Sustainability Issues, 2018, vol.6, issue 1, pp.398-410.
  • Lecluyse L., Knockaert M., Spithoven A. The contribution of science parks: a literature review and future research agenda // Journal of Technology Transfer, 2019, vol.44, issue 2, Special Issue: SI, pp.559-595.
  • Rawia A.O. Role of business incubators in the development of small and medium enterprises examples of international experiences // Journal of Business and Management (JBM), 2016, vol.18, issue 4, pp.26-46.
  • Hobbs K.G., Link A.N., Scott J.T. Science and technology parks: an annotated and analytical literature review // Journal of Technology Transfer, 2017, vol.42, issue 4, pp.957-976.
  • International Association of Science Parks and Areas of Innovation, 2019, http://www.iasp.ws.
  • Poonjan A., Tanner A.N. The role of regional contextual factors for science and technology parks: a conceptual framework // European Planning Studies, 2020, vol.28, issue 2, pp.400-420.
  • Alguliyev R.M., Mahmudov R.S. Topical issues of regulation of economic relations in Internet environment // Economics World, 2016, vol 4, no.1, pp.25-36.
  • Yang H., Kumara S., Bukkapatnam S., et al. The Internet of Things for smart manufacturing: A review // IISE Transactions, 2019, vol.51, no.11, pp.1190-1216.
  • Ширшова Л.В., Адиньяев С.И., Бучнева Д.Н. Проблемы и перспективы развития технопарков в России // Экономика и управление: проблемы, решения, 2017, Т.4,№5-2, с.71-76.
  • European Commission. Factories of the future multi-annual roadmap for the contractual PPP under Horizon 2020. Prepared by: European Factories of the Future Research Association (EFFRA) a Manufuture İnitiative, p.136. http://www.ec.europe.eu
  • Aliyev A.G., Shahverdiyeva R.O. Conceptual bases of intellectual management system of innovative technoparks // İnternational journal of Education and Management Engineering, 2017, №2, pp.1-7.
  • Magalhaes C., Maria A., da Claudimar V.P. Management model by processes for science parks // Cogent Business & Management,  2019, vol.6, issue 1,  Article Number: 1580121.
  • Əliyev Ə.Q., Şahverdıyeva R.O. İnnovativ strukturların fəaliyyətinin idarə edilməsinin konseptual əsasları // İnformasiya cəmiyyəti problemləri, 2014, №1, s.33-42.
  • Entringer T.C., da Lacopo S.L. Critical success factors in science and technology parks: a bibliographic review and analysis // Independent Journal of Management & Production, 2020, vol.11, issue 2, pp.343-359.
  • European Innovation Scoreboards (EIS)-2019 project for the European Commission, p.39, https://www.ec.europa.eu
  • Аккужин Ф.Р. Проблемы оценки инновационной деятельности технопарков // 
    Экономика и социум, 2019, №12(67), с.170-174.
  • Анохин А.Н. Методы экспертных оценок. Учебное пособие, Обнинск: ИАТЭ, 1996, 148 с.
  • Орлов А.И. Эконометрика? Издательство: «Экзамен», Москва, 2004, 576 с.
  • Балдин К.В. Концептуальные основы применения метода экспертного оценивания в предпринимательстве, Монография, Ухта: УГТУ, 2016, 110 с.
  • Мамедова М.Г., Джабраилова З.Г. Нечеткая многокритериальная модель поддержки принятия решений в задачах управления персоналом // Проблемы информационных технологий, 2012, №2, c.37–46.
  • Соколова М.Л., Градусов Д.А., Чернов В.Г. Моделирование и исследование метода многокритериального альтернативного выбора ELECTRE в условиях неопределенности экспертных оценок // Динамика сложных систем - XXI век, 2016, т. 10, №4, с.82-90.
  • Стебеняева Т.В., Ларина Т.С., Юдинова В.В. Система показателей для интегральной оценки качества инновационных программных проектов создания инновационной продукции, услуг и технологий // Успехи современной науки и образования, 2017, т. 2,№1, с.182-186.
  • Şahverdiyeva R.O. İnnovativ layihələrin səmərəlilik göstəriciləri və meyarları əsasında qiymətləndirilməsi məsələləri // İnformasiya texnologiyaları problemləri, 2020, №1, s. 129–141.
  • Aliyev A.G., Shahverdiyeva R.O. Application of mathematical methods and models in product – service manufacturing processes in scientific innovative technoparks // International Journal of Mathematical Sciences and Computing (IJMSC), 2018, vol.4, no.3, p.1-12.
  • Aliyev A.G., Shahverdiyeva R.O. Multi-level system of indicators on the activity of innovative technology parks in the sectors of information and knowledge economy // Management Dynamics in the Knowledge Economy, 2019, vol.7, no.1, pp.51-70.